Marshmallow run off

I had 2 ideas for the quote from Penny and her story; "My family around a bonfire toasting marshmallows on a summer evening and enjoying the night sky." It was late when I finished so I am posting now. Version one has the 3D marshmallow within the fire and the family in the background. I wanted it masked like memory so I poured wax over the image. The second image is the fire with a blue, night sky in profile and the family represented in toasted colors. Which one do you prefer?